Free legal Advisors

Connecting layman to lawman...

Free legal Advisors

Connecting layman to lawman...

Monday, 8 July 2013

Face Challenge and take initiative

George Bernard Shaw said, “Ordinary people adapt themselves to the world. The extra-ordinary persons try to adapt the world to them. Hence the progress and development of the world is through extra-ordinary people.”  Life itself is a challenge and the capacity to survive challenge in human beings is so great that either they find a way or make one. What are the most important qualities that these extraordinary people posses? They are always ready to face the challenges and they are always ready to take the initiatives. The many inventions and discoveries of the world by which the world has progressed are through the extraordinary people who have accepted the challenges against many odds and taken the initiatives to bring in the changes. There are no great people in this world, only great challenges which ordinary people rise to meet. By accepting the challenge they took the initiative to produce successful result and thereby they became great.  Challenges are what make the life so interesting and overcoming them is what makes life meaningful. When challenges are accepted, it will lead to the exhilaration of victory.

What is challenge?

When impediments and obstacles come in the way of achieving success, a challenge is created. Initiative is the step taken to meet these impediments and to overcome them so as to achieve success. Hence initiative is the natural corollary to meet the challenge. We don’t have to be great to start, but we have to start to be great. We all experience certain unexplained feelings which creates an impact in our thinking when faced with a challenge affecting whatever happens around us. But “Experience is not what happens to a man. It is what a man does with what happens to him.” Besides, “The ultimate measure of a man is not where he stands in moments of comfort and convenience, but where he stands in times of challenge and controversy.” That will determine what initiative he has to take.

What is initiative?

Initiative is the first step taken to achieve the desired result. It is the forerunner of action. Action produces the result. When the initiative is taken to act, it may face various challenges. Hence it is apparent that challenge and initiative are the two sides of the same coin and both of them are complimentary to each other. If initiative is taken, it may lead to challenges and if challenges are there, it requires initiative to surmount the challenge. “Life affords no higher pleasure than that of surmounting difficulties, passing from one step of success to another, forming new wishes and seeing them gratified. He that labors in any great or laudable undertaking has his fatigues first supported by hope and afterward rewarded by joy.”  George Bernard Shaw said “Some look at things that are, and ask why. I dream of things that never were and ask why not?”  We can dream only if we have hope because “Of all the forces that make for a better world, none is so indispensable, none so powerful, as hope. Without hope men are only half alive. With hope they dream and think and work.”

But human nature is that we are afraid to meet the challenge because we are afraid of the failure and we waste our energy trying to cover up our failure. Instead if we accept and learn from our failure taking it as a part of growing up, then only we will be able to face the next challenge and come out successfully. Accepting failure and working on it is the first step to success. Human tendency is to find difficulty in opportunity and not opportunity in difficulty. The general human behaviour is to take the path of least resistance. We tend to forget that when we meet greater challenges, we will find greater opportunities also by understanding our greater inner power dwelling in us. What we have to cultivate is a belief in ourselves and to understand our own capabilities to organise and execute the sources of action required to manage prospective situations.

When challenges are conquered through initiatives and actions taken, results are achieved and success is ensured. Then we understand that opportunities to find deeper powers within ourselves come when life seems most challenging. Challenges make us to discover things about ourselves that we never really know and they make us go beyond our normal stretch. “If we do not rise to the challenge of our unique capacity to shape our lives, to seek the kinds of growth that we find individually fulfilling, then we can have no security: we will live in a world of sham, in which our selves are determined by the will of others, in which we will be constantly buffeted and increasingly isolated by the changes round us.” Achievements in life depend upon the way in which we approach our tasks. When we accept tough jobs as a challenge to our ability and wade into them with joy and enthusiasm, miracles can happen. When we do our work with a dynamic, conquering spirit, we get things done. Success is the product of initiative and initiative is to do the right things at the right time and that too without being told. The initiative to face the challenge begins with a first move and a fresh approach and a new way of dealing with the challenge. Perseverance and persistence are the two qualities required to take the initiative to face the challenges and to produce success that we ardently seek. Attitude plays a key role to meet the challenges and to take the initiatives. “Success or failure is caused more by mental attitudes than my mental capabilities.”  And “No condition or set of circumstances is in itself a calamity to be feared. It is our reaction to it that makes it a ‘waterloo’ or a field of triumph.”

Challenges are met with by taking the initiative to action. But upon what we have to act?  It is said, “To look is one thing. To see what you look at is another. To understand what you see is a third. To learn from what you understand is still something else. But to act on what you learn is all that matters, Isn’t it?” Every human being has his own distinct personality coming out of their own perception and concept. The various characteristics of his personality control his behaviour, the ability to learn, capacity to grow and   his capability to change. A strong positive self image with an affirmative assertiveness is the best way to face challenges to achieve success. Cultivating the leadership qualities to apply to all facets of life and developing a competency that we can learn to expand our perspective so as to enable us to set the context of a goal by understanding the human behaviour, and taking the initiative to act will lead us to get to where we want to be.

In the ultimate analysis, “People with high assurance in their capabilities approach difficult task as challenges to be mastered rather than as threats to be avoided.” Success can be achieved by taking the right initiatives to meet the challenges that come in the way in every walk of life. We are more than what we know about us. By understanding our inner power, we are capable of taking initiative to meet any challenge that may come in our way and achieve whatever that we want through the power of positive thinking.  The ultimate endeavour of every one of us is to be a winner and a winner is.

JUST WRONG ”THE CJI CAN ADVISE DINAKARAN TO STOP WORK.”

It is strange that Karnataka High Court Chief Justice P D Dinakaran, against whom serious charges of encroachment and illegal occupation of public land, acquisition of wealth beyond known means and abuse of office have been leveled, still continues to discharge his judicial duties. The mere existence of charges against a person is no reason to take action against him or her. But in Justice Dinakaran’s case, at least one major charge has been found correct by an authorized government official. The Thiruvallur district collector has confirmed that ‘poromboke’ land in Kaverirajapuram in the district has been encroached upon by Justice Dinakaran. It was also reported that the district’s revenue officials were threatened and there was an attempt to remove evidence of encroachment. The judge’s explanations about the charges do not seem convincing.
His elevation to the Supreme Court has been held in abeyance on the basis of the preliminary inquiry. But the Chief Justice of India has ordered an assessment by the Survey of India to verify the veracity of the collector’s view. This is also strange. When a responsible government official has submitted a report after due consideration of facts, why should a second opinion be sought on the matter? Even if other charges against the judge are found baseless, the charge of encroachment of land makes his elevation to the Supreme Court unacceptable. And if he is not fit for the Supreme Court, he cannot continue as high court chief justice.
The credibility and prestige of the judiciary depend on the conduct and image of the judges. They have to be completely above suspicion. It is unfortunate that the Supreme Court’s collegium of judges, which recommends the selection of judges, dillydallied in Justice Dinakaran’s case. It had, in the first place, either failed to investigate the charges against him or glossed over them. And now even in the face of credible evidence against him, it has not conclusively rejected his candidature. Justice Dinakaran himself should have voluntarily kept himself away from judicial duties when the charges came into the open. He should have had enough respect for his position to do that. The CJI can advise him to stop attending to judicial work. It is also necessary to take recourse to action, prescribed by the constitution, against an errant judge, and other appropriate actions to penalize him for violations of the law.

New rules for valuation of perquisites for use of motor car

The Finance (No. 2) Act, 2009, has withdrawn the levy of Fringe Benefit Tax (“FBT”) on expenditure incurred by an employer on or after 1 April 2009. Consequently, by an employee benefits which were subject to FBT have been brought back within the ambit of perquisites and taxable in the hands of employees from the financial year (“F.Y.”) 2009-10 onwards.
The relevant rules required to compute the valuation of such perquisites were awaited ever since the change was brought about by the Finance Act. Theserules have now been notified on dated 18-12-2009 wide Notification No. 94120091F No. 14212512009-s 0 (TPL), by the Central Board of Direct Taxes and the existing Rule 3 and insertion of Rule 40F of the Income-TaxRules, 1962 (“The Rules”) has been substituted completely. The new rule 3 is deemed to have come into effect from 1 st day of April 2009.
MOTOR CAR
The perquisites value of a motor car provided by an employer both for official and personal use has been enhanced by Rs. 600 to 800 per month depending on the engine capacity of the car. Also, the perquisites valuation for employer-provided chauffeur in such cases has been increased from Rs. 600 per month to Rs. 900 per month.
The new valuation rules as prescribed by CBDT and the comparative analysis with the earlier perquisite rules (Rule 3) have in respect of motor car owned or hired by employer and provided for personal purposes (Partly or Fully) of employees is tabulated as under:
Nature of benefit provided bythe employer     Value of perquisite as pererstwhile rules     Value of perquisite as pererstwhile rules
Motor car is owned/ hired by employer
(a)     Car used exclusively in performance of official dutiesRule 3(2)(A)(1)(a)     No value provided specified documents1 are maintained by employer     Same as erstwhile provisions
(b)     Car used exclusively for personal purpose by the employee or any member of his household2 and expenses on maintenance and running are met/ reimbursed by employerRule 3(2)(A)(1)(b)     Actual amount of expenditure incurred including the remuneration paid to the chauffeur by the employerplus amount representing normal wear and tear of the car3
_____________
as reduced by any amount charged from the employee
Same as erstwhile provisions
(c) Car used partly for official duties and partly for personal purpose by employee or any member of his household
(i)    Expenses on maintenance and running are met/ reimbursed by employerRule 3(2)(A)(1)(c)(i)     Rs 1,200*4/Rs 1,600**5 per month (plus Rs 600 if chauffeur is provided)     Rs 1,800*Rs 2,400** per month (plus Rs 900 if chauffeur is provided)
(ii)     Expenses on maintenance and running for personal use are fully met by employeeRule 3(2)(A)(1)(c)(ii)     Rs 400*6Rs 600**7 per month (plus Rs 600 if chauffeur is provided)     Rs 600*/Rs 900** per month (plus Rs 900 if chauffeur is provided)
Note to above:-
1. Specified Documents:
(a)   Employer has maintained complete details of journey undertaken for official purpose which may include date of journey, destination, mileage, and the amount of expenditure incurred thereon
The employer gives a certificate to the effect that the expenditure 2.  Member of household includes spouse(s), children and their spouses, parents and servants and dependants
3.  The normal wear and tear of a motor car shall be taken @ 10% per annum of the actual cost of the motor car(s)
4 * Where cubic capacity of engine does not exceed 1.6 litres
5 ** Where cubic capacity of engine exceeds 1.6 litres
6 * Where cubic capacity of engine does not exceed 1.6 litres
7 ** Where cubic capacity of engine exceeds 1.6 litres
Nature of benefit provided by
the employer     Value of perquisite as per
erstwhile rules     Value of perquisite as per
new rules
Motor car is owned by employee and running expenses met or reimbursed by employer
(a)   Car used exclusively in performance of official duties
Rule 3(2)(A)(2)(i)
No value provided the specified documents1 are maintained by employer     Same as erstwhile provisions
(b)  Car used partly for official duties and partly for personal purpose by him or any member of his household     Actual amount incurred by employer
as reduced by Rs 1 ,200*/Rs 1,600** per month (plus Rs 600 if chauffeur is provided)
Actual amount incurred by employer
as reduced by Rs 1,800*/Rs 2,400** per month (plus Rs 900 if chauffeur is provided)
(Refer Note 2)
Rule 3(2)(A)(2)(ii)
Any other automotive conveyance is owned by employee and running and maintenance expenses are met/ reimbursed by employer
(a)   Used exclusively in performance of official duties
Rule 3(2)(A)(3)(i)
No value provided the specified documents are maintained by employer     Same as erstwhile provisions
(b)  Used partly for official duties and partly for personal purpose by him     Actual amount of expenditure incurred by employer as reduced by Rs 1,200*/Rs 1,600** per month (plus Rs 600 if chauffeur is provided)     Actual amount of expenditure incurred by employer as
reduced by Rs 900 per month
* Refer Note 2
Rule 3(2)(A)(3)(ii)
1. Specified Documents:
(a)   Employer has maintained complete details of journey undertaken for official purpose which may include date of journey, destination, mileage, and the amount of expenditure incurred thereon
(b)   The employer gives a certificate to the effect that the expenditure was incurred wholly and exclusively for performance of official duties
2: Wherein the employer or employee claims:
-                        that motor car has been used exclusively in performance of office duties,
or
-           actual expenses on running and maintenance of the car owned by employee
is more than the amounts deductible as specified, then he may claim a higher amount attributable to such use and the value of the perquisite shall be actual amount attributable to official use of the vehicle, provided the specified documents are maintained by employer.

Nature Of Copyright Infringement In Internet

With the mergence of the internet and increasing use of the worldwide web possibilities of infringement of copyright have become mind boggling free and easy access on the web together with possibilities of down loading has created new issued in copyright infringement. Taking content from one site, modifying it or just reproducing it on another site has been made possible by digital technology and this has posed new challenges for the traditional interpretation of individual rights and protection. Any person with a PC (Personal Computers) and a modem can become a publisher. Downloading, uploading saving transforming or crating a derivative work is just a mouse click away.
A web page is not much different than a book a magazine or a multimedia CD-Rom and will be eligible for copyright protection, as it contains text graphics and even audio and videos.
Copyright law grants the owner exclusive right to authorize reproduction of the copy righted works preparation of derivative works, distribution etc. However application of this concept on the internet cannot be strictly applied to copyright. Duplication of the information is an essential step in the transmission of information on the internet and even plain browsing information at a computer terminal (which is equivalent to reading a book or a magazine at book store) may result in the creation of an unauthorized copy since a temporary copy of the work is created in the RAM of the users computer for the purpose of access. The law on the subject evolving and the general view is that more accessing a web page would not be an infringement as the copy created is temporary or ephemeral. Another common issue amongst web site owners is to create links to other sites within the design of their own web pages. Would such linking be considered a copy right violation as these links give access to other copy righted sites? Although strictly speaking it may be a violation of copyright. But there is an implied doctrine of public access for linking to other web pages. The Internet was created on the basic of being able to attach hypertext links to any other location and it is assumed that once a page is put on the net, implied consent is given, unless specifically prohibited by the web site owner.

Marital break up must not Traumatise sons

The high and mighty are beyond reproach. However, the life of a public figure is like an open book, and any citizen can read any page. I sympathize with Shri Omar Abdullah and Smt Payal Nath, husband and wife, for the marital predicament that they are in at the moment. I wish the couple come out of this difficult situation of marital separation and live together as husband and wife once again. They will be bringing up their two sons better as parents. Separation means the children will be brought up by a single parent, perhaps the mother, and it may cause an impediment in the development of a well rounded personality of the two boys. The heart of an impartial observer bleeds for the boys.

There is no use of going into the reasons that caused this separation. Now it has to be accepted as a fait accompanies.  Shri Omar did well to clarify his position that he is not contemplating to tie the nuptial knot again. The two young ladies, one of the Delhi media world and the other of a political family of the Kashmir valley were dragged into this quagmire unnecessarily. We should take Omar’s word for it that he is not contemplating to  make anyone of the two charming young ladies  his bride. let us leave it at that.

I shall be failing in my duty if I do not counsel the separated couple to take the unpleasant break up in the normal stride of life. They should not avoid seeing each other but make it a point to meet at a public place along with their two sons for the sake of sons’ smooth life in future.

PUBLIC DUTY

It is nice of Shri Omar Abdullah to reassure the citizens of India that while he went through the trials and tribulations of this pre-separation period, he did not let the State of J&K suffer or feel ignored by its own Chief Minister. The affairs of State take precedence over private matters, no matter how sad the latter may be. Their marriage was on the rocks-this perception was shared by the high and the low both. It was talk of the town and was doing damage to both the families; of the husband and that of the wife.

A gossip is a gossip and gossip mongers are there in all strata of the society. Gossip mongers flourish because men and women who are well provided for but have ample time at their disposal, find rumour mongering an engaging pastime. It keeps the rumour mongers in circulation and many a time he earns a meal at the table of the rich who have ample time to while away. A popular saying in Hindi runs thus: “per ninda param sukham” that is berating others and indulging in character assassination of the known and the unknown gives the wily critic joy unbound. A word of caution before one entertains the remotest idea of getting a free lunch by rumour mongering and character assassination. Firstly, there is no free lunch in this world. One pays for it directly or indirectly. Secondly, the rumour mongers are looked down upon in a civilized society. Their presence in civil society is not welcome. Many wily persons entertain them but such occasions are few and far between.

Returning to Omar and Payal, we find that Payal has maintained a lady like silence so far. Perhaps her culture of thousands of years inherited from generation to generation forbids her to wash her dirty linen in public. This washing causes pain to the members of the inner circle and gives no joy to the cultured elements in the social order. A Hindi couplet sums up pain and silence in a situation like this :

Rahiman nij man ki vyatha man hi rakho goye; sun ithalaiyen sabau, baant na lehiyen koe.

Abdur Rahim Khanekhanan of Emperor Akbar’s court said that it would be wise to keep your vexing problem inside yourself. If you narrate to others, listeners will make fun of you and enjoy at your cost; none will share your predicament.


As a citizen of India I share the sadness of Omar and Payal and advise them to keep the marital anguish to themselves lest the world laughs at you and shares not your personal pain.

Bail is the rule, jail an exception, observes SC

Maintaining that bail is the rule and jail an exception, the Supreme Court on Wednesday said both seriousness of the charge and severity of punishment should be taken into account while determining bail. “Deprivation of liberty must be considered a punishment. When the undertrial prisoners are detained in jail for an indefinite period, Article 21 of the Constitution is violated,” said a bench of justice GS Singhvi and justice HL Datt while granting bail to five executives in the 2G spectrum scam.

It added: “The court owe more than verbal respect to the principle that punishment begins after conviction and that every man is deemed to be innocent until duly tried and duly found guilty.”

The five, Unitech Wireless MD Sanjay Chandra, Swan Telecom director Vinod Goneka and Reliance ADAG executives — Hari Nair, Gautam Doshi and Surendra Pipara — were in jail for seven months. They had moved SC challenging May 23 Delhi high court verdict declining them bail. The HC had affirmed the trial court order.

Both courts had denied bail to them, observing they faced serious corruption charges. The SC termed both orders as against the “normal rule of bail system”.

“Every person, detained or arrested, is entitled to speedy trial,” it held, noting since 2G  trial may take considerable time the accused may end up in jail longer than the period of sentence, if found guilty.

Kanimozhi seeks early bail hearing
Encouraged by the SC order granting bail to five corporate executive, DMK MP Kanimozhi and five other accused, moved the Delhi HC for early hearing of their bail plea. It is scheduled for December 1.

How Indian is Constitution of India

The Constitution of India was framed by the Constituent Assembly that was absolutely Indian. An overwhelming majority of members of the body that enacted the most important document for governance of Bharat and observe Rule of Law comprised freedom fighters who had given their best to making India free. Their credentials were above reproach. Our Founding Fathers of the Constitution enjoyed the love, respect and admiration of people of India. People loved the members of the Constituent Assembly and got love in  return in abundance.

FEATURES OF INDIANNESS

Language, culture, dress, education, Sanskars and above all the Mindset go to make the Indianness or otherwise of our Constitution. The vast majority of constitution makers came from villages of India. They were soaked in the soil, water and air of India. Regretfully they were not allowed to have their say in matters constitutional.

Leaders like Jawaharlal Nehru, Sardar Patel, Dr Rajendra Prasad, Dr Bhimrao Ambedkar and many legal luminaries dominated the  proceedings of the Constituent Assembly from A to Z. The semi-literate Ram and Ghanshyam followed no English, what to say of legal language in a foreign tongue. Their presence in the Hall was the only contribution that they could make. Thus the Constitution of India in its final shape did not have an imprint of the People of India, notwithstanding the fact that it was enacted, adopted by the People of India and promulgated by the People of India just two months after  enactment and being signed by one and allconcerned with it.

The Constitution was a finished product in a book form on26 November 1949. It was adopted on 26 January 1950 and then the same day the Republic of India came into being.

One regrets to note that despite all factors being favourable to India and Indians, the Constitution of India lacked an Indian soul that was needed to make it effective at the ground roots level.
The Constitution of India failed the litmus test of being Indian in charagter. It was everything but a document for the People, by the People and of the People of India that is Bharat. What a pity that the members of that agust body, the Constituent Assembly failed to give just one Indian name tothe motherland. It is called India that is Bharat.
The founding fathers of the Constitution of India were in favour of adopting just one national anthem – vande mataram. What a shame the present national anthem jana gana mana came from behind riding the shoulders of Jawaharlal Nehru and usurped the throne. The whole country regrets that dacoity till this day.

FEATRES OF OUR CONSTITUTION

The Constitution of India is a written document and is relied solely on its text by the judiciary. Unlike the British constitution which is by and large convention and tradition based and is in written form to a minor degree.
, the Indian constitution gives a little leeway to judicial interpretation where written word is clear in its intent. Indeed the Supreme Court and the High Court have the constitutional mandate for a Judicial Review and their interpretation is not only  the Last Word in the matter but also lays down law of the land.
The Judiciary ensures that the country is  governed by the provisions of law and that the Rule of Law will be respected and obeyed always. The  jurisprudence lays down:
HOWEVER HIGH YOU MAY EVER BE,
THE LAW IS ABOVE YOU.

The Fundamental Rights and the Directive Principles are a part of the Constitution of India. It has 395 Articles and Nine Schedules. With the result, the Indian Constitution is a bulky book, difficult to carry and harder to understand in letter and spirit. It falls on the strong shoulders of the Indian Judiciary to interpret the Constitution of India for the benefit of the People of India.