Free legal Advisors

Connecting layman to lawman...

Free legal Advisors

Connecting layman to lawman...

Tuesday, 2 July 2013

Administrative instructions

Administrative instructions:

Over fifty years back Holmes J in Bain Peanut Company of Texas V Dave Pinson (1930) 75 Law Ed.482 at page 491 said that “we must remember that the machinery of the Government would not work, if it were not allowed a little play in its joints. We should not allow administrative or executive efficiency to flounder on the rock of avoidable technicality. It is well to remember that administrative and executive efficiency or exigency should not be too readily sacrificed”. Such should be the result, if the instruction is given a mandatory force. State would be completely deprived of much needed play in its joints. Absolute enactments must be obeyed or fulfilled exactly, but it is sufficient if a directory enactment be obeyed or fulfilled substantially.

In bigger form of administration, issuance of administrative direction is an essential element. Without the directions, it would be impossible for the Government to run the administration that effectively. The constitution provides for the “Executive Function”. Specified authority may issue directions, as it may deem fit and proper to harmonize and properly guide the downstream. Generally, the administrative officers have to deal with the matters and they have to face the day to day problems. Every time, it may not be possible to enact the ‘legislative code’. The directions are issued by the government in the form of circulars, resolutions, bylaws, trade notices and similar other forms. These directions would bring desired flexibility in the administration coupled with certainty or uniformity in identical matters.

Once the Government has issued the directions, the subordinate executives have to discharge their responsibility consistently with the directions and those directions are binding upon the state officers. The discretion has to be governed preliminary on the basis of the administrative policy contained in the circular, Resolution or such other similar instrument. Any attempt to disobey the direction of the department may expose the concerned officer for disciplinary actions and remedies for breach of direction is inter departmental.

Enforceability and identification:

It is not necessary that for issuing “direction” source of statutory power is required. Ordinarily, field is covered under the “Executive Function” of the Government. The Government also derives powers under the “Rules of Business”. These directions have confused the area in administrative law. The courts are interpreting the same from time to time and from case to case. The directions are normally not enforceable, but courts have drawn certain exception.

Interpreting or holding that the executive instructions are directory does not mean that they can be ignored with impunity. Even directory provisions are not meant to be violated. It was held in Pratap v. Shri Krishna Gupta AIR 1956 SC 140 that some rules are vital and go to the root of the matter; they cannot be broken; others are only directory and a breach of them can be overlooked provided there is substantial compliance with the rules read as a whole and no prejudice ensues; and when legislature does not itself state which is which Judges must determine the matter and, exercising a nice discrimination, sort out one class from the other along broad based, commonsense lines.

Some administrative directions are held to have the statutory force while some directions are held to have mere administrative force or character. The administrative domain is using the words like code, regulations, bylaws and the rules, but they may not be real “Delegated Legislation”. Indiscriminate use of these substitutions results in confusion. At the same time, some Judgments of the Court have also created confusion. The lawyers in the administrative field are busy to seek identification of directions. They are keen to see how the courts interpret the particular directions. It is the interpretation of the direction upon which the ultimate right of the litigating party depends. If these directions have, statutory force then there is hardly any scope for dispute. They are simply enforceable and courts may consequent upon such violation of the directions grant suitable relief. The situation would be converse, if they are held merely administrative directions having no statutory force.

G. J. Fernandez

In G. J. Fernandez, the Mysore Public works Department Code was held to have contained mere administrative instructions though coached as “code”.

The Court observed that:

“Article 162 does not confer any power on the state government to frame rules and it only indicates the scope of the executive power of the state. Of course, under such executive power, the state can give administrative instructions to its serventies how to act in certain circumstances, but that will not make such instructions statutory rules that are justifiable in certain circumstances. In order that such executive instructions have the force of statutory rules, it must be shown that they have been issued either under the authority covered on the state Government by some statute or under some provision of the constitution providing therefore. There is no statute that confers any authority on the state Government to issue rules in matters with which the Mysore Public Works Department Code is concerned. Thus, the instructions contained in the code are mere administrative instructions and not statutory rules. Therefore, even if there has been any breach of such executive instructions that does not confer any right on any member of the public to ask for a right against Government by a petition under Art. 226. It is a matter between the State Government and its servant.”

V. T. Khanzode’s Case

This is an interesting matter decided by the supreme Court of India dealing with the questions firstly, whether the Reserve Bank of India (Staff) Regulations, 1948 are statutory in character, secondly, whether it is competent for the Bank to provide conditions of service of its staff by administrative circulars, and thirdly, whether the impugned circular and seniority list offend against the provision of Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution. The contention of the petitioner was that the Regulations were framed under section 58 of the Reserve Bank of India Act, 1934, that they cannot be altered by administrative circulars, that conditions of service cannot be framed by administrative circulars but must be made by Regulations made under section 58 of the Act etc.

Section 58(1) provides that:

“The Central board may, with the previous sanction of the Central Government, make regulations consistent with this act to provide for all matters for which provision is necessary or convenient for the purpose of giving effect to the provisions of this Act.”

Sub section 2 of the Act provides that without prejudice to the generality of the foregoing provision, such regulation may provide for all or any of the matters mentioned in various clauses of that sub section.

It was contended that the Central Board had no inherent power and they must seek and find their power and obligation under the Act (Charter of Creation). Therefore, the argument proceeded that it is imperative on the Bank to provide the conditions of service only by way of regulations duly framed and cannot be framed by administrative circular issued in the exercise of non-statutory power or authority.

In this connection reliance was placed on Halsbury:

“Corporations may be either statutory or non-statutory, and a fundamental distinction exists between the powers and liabilities of the two classes, statutory corporations have such rights and can do such acts only as are authorized directly or indirectly by the Statutes creating them, non-statutory corporation, speaking generally can do everything that an ordinary individual can do unless restricted directly or indirectly by statute.’’

“The powers of a corporation created by statute are limited and circumscribed by the statute which regulate it, and extend no further that is expressly stated therein, or is necessarily and properly regard for carrying out into effect the purposes of its corporations incorporation’s, or may be fairly regarded as incidental to, or consequential upon, those things which the legislature has authorized, what the statute does not expressly or impliedly authorize is to be taken to be prohibited.”

The statement of law in Halsbury puts an emphasis on the limitation on powers of statutory corporations in light of the provisions of statutes under which they are constituted.

The language of the Regulation 58(1) is very clear, the court held that so long as the regulations governing conditions of service are not framed, the central Board had the authority under section 7(2) of the Act to issue administrative circulars and thus govern the conditions of service. The Court held that:

“It would therefore be wrong to deny to the Central Board the power to issue administrative directions of service of the Bank’s staff. To read into the provisions of 5.58(1) a prohibition against the issuance of such administrative directions or circulars is patently to ignore the scope of the wholesome powers conferred upon the Central Board of Directors by 2, 7(2) of the Act. Indeed. This section brings the impugned circular and seniority list within the rule mentioned in Halsbury: they have the authority of the statute.” (Para 19 of reports)

In Para 20 of the reports, the Court further held that:

“While issuing the administrative circular governing the staff’s conditions of service, the Central Board of Directors has neither violated any statutory injunction nor indeed has it exercised a power which is not conferred upon by the statute. The circulars are strictly within the confines of S, 7(2).”

K. P. Joseph’s Case

In this case, the Union of India issued a memorandum fixing the salary of the re-employed Civil Servants. The Respondent contended that the memorandum is enforceable and his pay should be fixed accordingly. The Government took the contention that the memorandum is not enforceable, as the same does not confer any enforceable right in view of the fact that it has no statutory force. It was argued that the same was having a flavour of administrative character.

The Supreme Court said that:

“Generally speaking, an administrative order confer no justifiable right, but this rule, like all other general rules is subject to exception. To say that an administrative order can never confer any right would be too wide a proposition. There are administrative orders which confer rights and impose duties.”

The Supreme Court said that the Respondent had a right to claim his salary fixed in accordance with the memorandum issued by the government, but at the same time observed that the Court is not laying down a general proposition.

Anglo Afghan Agencies Case

In this case, the Supreme Court enforced the administrative instructions holding that the Union of India was not justified in falling back on the promise held out to the Citizens.

The Textile Commissioner published a Scheme called “Export Promotion Scheme” providing for incentives to exporters of woolen goods. Under the scheme, the Exporter was required to be registered and in that case, only he could get the “entitlement certificate for 100% import of goods.” The Import Entitlement Certificate was given at a reduced rate under the direction of the executive wing. The petitioner instituted a petition challenging the legality and validity of the impugned action. The petitioner succeeded in the petition. The Union of India then filed an appeal before the Supreme Court and attempted to relieve itself from the solemn promise. The Court held that:

“Granting that it was executive in character, the Courts have the powers in appropriate cases to compel performance of the obligation imposed by the schemes upon the departmental authorities. It could not be said that the executive necessity releases promises relying upon which citizens have acted to their detriment. Under the constitutional set up, no person may be deprived of his right or liberty except in due course of and by authority of law, if a member of the executive seeks to deprive a citizen of his right or liberty otherwise than in exercise of power derived from the law common or statute the courts will be competent to, and indeed would be bound to protect the rights of the aggrieved citizen”.

In the present case the scheme was published under the Imports and Exports (Control) Act, 1947, but it was held to be administrative in character. Court also took into consideration that there is no pattern of order or logical sequence in the policy statement. It is a jumper of executive instructions and matters that impose several restrictions and restrictions upon the rights of the citizens. Some of the provisions that impose restrictions upon citizens in the exercise of their right to carry on trade without statutory limits may be open to serious objections. The Supreme Court, however, did not answer the question on this count but held the government bound on the basis of the representation made by the union of India under the Scheme.

Sukhdev Singh v. Bhagatram

The contention of the employees in this case was that “Regulations” are made under the statute. Origin and source of power to make Regulation is statutory. Regulations are self-binding in character. Regulations have the force of law, in as much as; the statutory authorities have no right to make any departure from the regulations. As against this, the contention of the State was that regulations framed under powers given by the statute affecting matters of internal management, regulations do not have the statutory binding character. Terms and conditions laid down in the regulations are not matters of statutory obligations. Regulations are not binding as law but as contract. Regulations provide for the terms and conditions of employment and thereafter the employment of each person is contractual. If the regulations are held to be administrative in character, the contention should have prevailed. But the Supreme Court took it otherwise. Rules, Regulations, bylaws, orders made under the statutory powers are all comprised in delegated legislation. The need for delegated legislation is that statutory rules are framed with care and minuteness when the statutory authority making the rules after the coming into force of the act in a better position to adapt the act to special circumstances. Delegated legislation permits utilization of experience and consultation with interests affected by the practical operations of statutes. A person or body by virtue of the powers conferred by a statute makes subordinate legislation. Bylaws are made in the main by local authorities or similar bodies or by statutory or other undertakings for regulating the conduct of persons within their area or resorting to their undertakings. Regulations may determine the class of cases in which the exercise of the statutory power by any such authority constitutes the making of statutory rule. The word “rules” and “regulations” are used to limit the power of the statutory bodies. They are controlled and restricted by their statutes that create them and the rules and regulations framed thereunder. Any action of such bodies in excess of their power of or in violation of the restrictions placed in their powers is ultra vires. The reason is that it goes to the root of the power of such corporations and the declaration of nullity is the only relief that is granted to the aggrieved party.

In England subordinate legislation has, if validly made, the full force and effect of a statute, but it differs from a statute in that its validity whether as respects form or substance is normally open to challenge in the courts. The subordinate legislation has full force as if enacted like statute. The Supreme Court observed that:

“The noticeable feature is that there statutory bodies have no free hand in framing the conditions and terms of service of their employees. These statutory bodies are bound to apply the terms and conditions as laid down in the regulations. The statutory bodies are not free to make such terms, as they think fit and proper. Regulations prescribe the terms of appointment, conditions of service and procedure for dismissal.”

The Court further observed it that:

“Broadly stated, the distinction between rules and regulations on the one hand and administrative instructions on the other hand is that rules and regulations can be made only after reciting the source of power whereas administrative instructions are not issued after reciting source of power, second the executive power of a state is not authorized to frame rules under Article 162. This court held that the public works department code was not a subordinate legislation’s (See G. J. Fernandez v. State of Mysore, 1967 3 SCR 636= (AIR 1967 SC 1753. The rules under Article 309 on the other hand constitute not only the constitutional rights of relationship between the state and the Government Servants but also establish that there must be specific power to frame rules and regulations.” (Para 24)

The Supreme Court held that the regulations so framed assumed statutory force and therefore enforceable at law. The employees of the corporation were thus held entitled for relief of reinstatement etc.

Sant Ram’s Case

The Petitioner before the Supreme Court challenged the legality and validity of the Impugned action superseding him from the post of Inspector General of Police. Indian Police Service (Regulation of Seniority) Rules, 1954 came into force and accordingly the gradation list of all officers concerned had to be prepared in order to ascertain the chances of promotion. The Petitioner complained that he was discriminated and that he has a right for promotion to the post. The Government according to administrative practice issued letters and/or directions saying that:

“If a person, though senior in the gradation list, is appointed to the selection post later than his junior, this is presumable because he is superseded as a matter of selection. If this is so, it would certainly not be justified to regard the officer so selected earlier, though junior in the gradation list, as senior to the other officers, as far as the selection posts are concerned”.

Another communication runs like this:

“All super-time scale posts are selection posts and appointment thereto need not follow the order of seniority.”

It was contended on behalf of the petitioner that in the absence of statutory provision in the rule, the Government cannot issued the administrative instructions and also cannot impose restrictions by making administrative directions not found in the rules.

The Court held that:

“It is true that there is no specific provision in the rules laying down the principle of promotion of junior or senior grade officers to selection posts. But that does not mean that till statutory rules are framed in this behalf the Government cannot issue administrative instructions regarding the principle to be followed in promotions of the officers concerned to selection grade posts. It is true that Government cannot amend or supersede statutory rules by administrative instructions, but if the rules are silent on any particular point Government can fill up the gaps and supplement the rules and issue instructions not inconsistent with the rules already framed.”

The court thus held that the Government has power to issue such administrative instructions in the absence of statutory rules framed in regard to principle to be followed and simultaneously observed that the administrative instructions should be so issued which should not supersede the vigor of the rule or say such instructions should not be inconsistent with the statutory rules already framed. Thus Government can issue the instructions under its administrative powers to fill up the gap where the rules are silent or the rules are not framed.

BUREAUCRACY IS KILLING RTI

Processes, procedures, principles and the people responsible are as much important for a system as its purpose. If any of these is not up to the mark, it will defeat the very purpose for which the system has been put in place. The Right to Information Act is one such system which enables citizens to obtain information in the custody and possession of any public authority provided the same is not otherwise barred by the Act.
It is not that the people were not getting information they required from various Government departments before the enactment of RTI. They certainly were through dubious and illegal means like bribing. However, the Act, no doubt, has helped to some extent in promoting transparency, openness and accountability in the working of the public authorities.
While the new law is invested with some empowering provisions aimed at containing rampant corruption in the corridors of power, the corruption-ridden bureaucracy has left no stone unturned to blunt RTI’s effectiveness. First, the bureaucrats persuaded the Cabinet Committee to approve an Amendment to exempt file notings and Cabinet papers from disclosure under the Act. It was only due to the huge public outcry against the proposed Amendment that the malafide move was foiled.
Then came another assault that dealt a severe blow to RTI and has proved to be its undoing. Ostensibly brought about for better internal management of the affairs of the Central Information Commission so as to enable it to function effectively, the dubious Central Information Commission (Management) Regulations, 2007, has actually put RTI beyond the reach of a common man by rendering the process of seeking information under the Act an exorbitantly expensive, unduly complicated, cumbersome and lengthy affair. On top of this, the clever bureaucracy is so skilled in the art of dodging and has so many tricks up its dirty sleeves to smother inconvenient queries that it easily gets away without supplying the information requested.
RTI needs to be structured in such a manner that the role of the bureaucracy is minimal and simply restricted to supplying the requested information and/or the requested documents, and see to it that the information supplied is correct and complete. Beyond that it should have no role or influence in the RTI process. Otherwise, it can seriously damage the credibility of RTI.

What is Service??

What constitutes ‘Service’ is certainly a subject matter of discussion. Its plain meaning is an Act of helpful Activity or Rendering of Assistance or Help. Service is generally a feeling in the form of efforts and excludes sale of goods or property or commodities. It pre-supposes existence of a Service Provider. For Service Tax purposes, if there is no Service, then there should be no Tax.
‘Somebody’ wrote these beautiful lines which truly reflects the concept of ‘Service’ in our day to day life.
“Somebody did a golden deed; Somebody proved a friend in need; Somebody sang a beautiful song; Somebody smiled the whole day long; Somebody thought, it’s sweet to live; Somebody said, I’m glad to give; Somebody fought a valiant fight; Somebody lived to shield the right; that somebody is aservice provider.”
Even though Tax has been imposed on the Services by introducing Chapter–V in the Finance Act 1994, but the term ‘Service’ has not been defined in Act or Rules or by way of any explanation.
What is ‘Service’ under various popular Dictionary meaning ?
Service has been defined differently under various Dictionaries.
Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia defines economic sense of Service as to, the non-material equivalent of a good in economics and marketing.
A service is the diametrically opposed non-material counter-piece of a physical good. A service provision comprises a sequence of activities that does not result in ownership of the outcome, and this is what fundamentally differentiates it from furnishing someone with physical goods. Service provision is a process that creates predetermined benefits by effectuating a change of service consumers, a change in their physical possessions or a change in their tangible or intangible assets.
‘Service’ definition:
The generic clear-cut, complete and concise definition of the ‘service’ term reads as follows:
A ‘service’ is a set of singular and perishable benefits-
* delivered from the accountable service provider, mostly in close co-action with his service suppliers,
* generated by functions of technical systems and/or by distinct activities of individuals, respectively,
* commissioned according to the needs of his service consumers by the service customer from the accountable service provider,
* rendered individually to an authorized service consumer at his/her dedicated request,
* and, finally, consumed and utilized by the requesting service consumer for executing and/or supporting his/her day-to-day business tasks or private activities.
The concept of Service can be more definitely explained with the understanding of the following examples:
Work done by one person that benefits another person.
Work done for others as an occupation or business: has done service for us as a consultant.
Installation, maintenance, or repairs provided or guaranteed by a dealer or manufacturer: a dealer with full parts and service.
An act or a variety of work done for others, especially for pay: offers a superior service to that of his competitors; provides full catering services.
An act of assistance or benefit; a favor.
The serving of food or the manner in which it is served.
To make fit for use; adjust, repair, or maintain: service a car.
Type of business that sells assistance and expertise rather than a tangible product: the field of management consulting is a service industry.
Useful labor performed by an individual or organization on behalf of others: Doctors, lawyers, interior decorators, etc. provide services for which they are paid by their clients.
What is ‘Service’ under Commercial Laws of the Country ?
Now, we may consider the concept of Service as envisaged under the various commercial laws of India is more or less same in the Commercial Laws.
In contract law, service refers to an act or deed, rather than property.
‘Service’ under the Income Tax means Service of any description which is made available to potential users and includes the Provision of services in connection with business of any industrial or commercial nature such as accounting, banking, communication, conveying of news or information, advertising, entertainment, amusement, education, financing, insurance, chit funds, real estate, construction, transport, storage, processing, supply of electrical or other energy, boarding and lodging.
Under the Monopolies and Restrictive Trade Practices Act, Service means service of any description which is made available to potential users and includes the provisions of facilities in-connection with banking financing, insurance, chit fund,real estate , transport, processing, supply of electrical or other energy, board or lodging or both, entertainment, amusement or the conveying of news or other information butdoes not include the rendering of any service free of charge or under a contract of personal service.
Explanation.— For the removal of doubts, it is hereby declared that any dealings in real estate shall be included and shall be deemed always to have been included within the definition of ‘service’.
As per the Consumer Protection Act 1986, Service means service of any description which is made available to potential users and includes the provisions of facilities in connection with banking, financing, insurance transport processing, supply of electrical or other energy, board or lodging or both, entertainment, amusement or the purveying of news or other information, butdoes not include the rendering of any service free of charge or under a contract of personal service.
Under the Foreign Exchange Management Act, 1999, Service means service of any description which is made available to potential users and includes the provisions of facilities in connection with banking financing, insurance, medicalassistance, legal assistance, chit fund, real estate , transport, processing, supply of electrical or other energy, boarding or lodging or both, entertainment, amusement or the purveying of news or other information, butdoes not include the rendering of any service fee of charge or under a contract of personal service.
Under the Trademarks Act, 1999 and Competition Act, 2002, Service means service of any description which is made available to potential users and includes the provision of services in connection with business of any industrial or commercial matters such as banking, communication, education, financing, insurance, chit funds,real estate , transport, storage, material treatment, processing, supply of electrical or other energy, boarding, lodging, entertainment, amusement, construction, repair, conveying of news or information and advertising.
As per the International Accounting for Business, Service means something provided, usually for a fee, that may not be classed as manufacturing or production in any form (such as legal advice, brokerage, agency services and financial advice).
Characteristics of Service:
Services can be paraphrased in terms of their generic key characteristics.
1. Intangibility
-Services are intangible and insubstantial: they may not be touched, gripped, handled, looked at, smelled, tasted or heard. Thus, there is neither potential nor need for transport, storage or stocking of services. Furthermore, a service cannot be (re)sold or owned by somebody, neither can it be turned over from theservice provider to the service consumer nor returned from the service consumer to the service provider.
Solely, the service delivery can be commissioned to a service provider who must generate and render the service at the distinct request of an authorized service consumer.
2. Perishability
Services are perishable in two regards
* The relevant resources, processes and systems are assigned for service delivery during a definite period in time. If the designated or scheduled service consumer does not request and consume the service during this period, the service cannot be performed for him. From the perspective of the service provider, this is a lost economic opportunity. Examples: An empty seat on a plane never can be utilized and charged after departure.
* When the service has been completely rendered to the requesting service consumer, this particular service irreversibly vanishes as it has been consumed by the service consumer. Example: the passenger has been transported to the destination and cannot be transported again to this location at this point in time.
3. Inseparability
The service provider is indispensable for service delivery as he must promptly generate and render the service to the requesting service consumer. In many cases the service delivery is executed automatically but the service provider must assign resources and systems and actively keep up appropriate service delivery readiness and capabilities. Additionally, the service consumer is inseparable from service delivery because he is involved in it from requesting it up to consuming the rendered benefits. Example: The service consumer must sit in the hair dresser’s shop & chair or on the seat in plane; correspondingly, the hair dresser or the pilot must be in the same shop or plane, respectively, for delivering the service.
4. Simultaneity
Services are rendered and consumed during the same period of time. As soon as the service consumer has requested the service (delivery), the particular service must be generated from scratch without any delay and friction and the service consumer instantaneously consumes the rendered benefits for executing his upcoming activity or task.
5. Variability
Each service is unique. It is one-time generated, rendered and consumed and can never be exactly repeated as the point of time, location, circumstances, conditions, current configurations and/or assigned resources are different for the next delivery, even if the same service consumer requests the same service. Many services are regarded as heterogeneous or lacking homogeneity and are typically modified for each service consumer or each new situation (customized). Example: The taxi service which transports the service consumer from his home to the opera is different from the taxi service which transports the same service consumer from the opera to his home – another point in time, the other direction, maybe another route, probably another taxi driver and cab.
Each of these characteristics is retractable per se and their inevitable co-incidence complicates the consistent service conception and make service delivery a challenge in each and every case. From the service consumer’s point of view, these characteristics make it difficult, or even impossible, to evaluate or compare services prior to experiencing the service delivery.
Mass generation and delivery of services is very difficult. This can be seen as a problem of inconsistent service quality. Both inputs and outputs to the processes involved providing services are highly variable, as are the relationships between these processes, making it difficult to maintain consistent service quality. For many services there is labor intensity as services usually involve considerable human activity, rather than a precisely determined process; exceptions include utilities.
Human resource management is important. The human factor is often the key success factor in service economies. It is difficult to achieve economies of scale or gain dominant market share. There are demand fluctuations and it can be difficult to forecast demand. Demand can vary by season, time of day, business cycle, etc.
There is consumer involvement as most service provision requires a high degree of interaction between service consumer and service provider. There is a customer- relationship based on creating long-term business relationships. Accountants, attorneys, and financial advisers maintain long-term relationships with their clients for decades. These repeat consumers refer friends and family, helping to create a client-based relationship.
Thus, literally, ‘Service’ can be said to have the following salient features :
— Act of helpful activity
— Act of doing something useful
— Rendering of assistance/help
— Anything which does not involve supply or transfer of goods is service
— Transformation of user/user goods as a result of voluntary intervention of service provider
— Intangible commodity in form of human effort
— Excludes sale of goods or commodities or property
— Existence of service provider and service recipient.

BSA, NASSCOM, NITSC & Security Policy

BSA (Business Software Alliance) recommended to put under US 301 list to those countries which lack rules to preserve and protect intellectual property right and who failed to follow vigorous enforcement action against software theft.
In a recent survey by the computer society of India reveals that almost one out of every two InfoTech companies in India has had its network broken into by hackers. And there out of every four companies acknowledge that there was some financial loss involve in such an attack, which attract two companies claiming that they lost $500 000 per instruction [16]
Robert Hollyman, chief executive of the Washington based BSA has estimated that the loss to the software developers on account of software piracy may be upto $1 billion a year. Through monitoring BSA has detected as many as 95,000 websites which offer pirated software called “Warez” by hackers.
In India, the National Association of software and Service Companies (NASSCOM) has proposed the setting up of a National Cybercrop Committee to provide helping hand to government and private agencies to combat against cyber hacking.
Hacking is an endless game. Whenever a new security device is announced, hackers take intellectual pleasure by cracking it. Six major security technologies that are connected to global net are: Firewalls, Anti-virus software, security scanner, internet protocol security (IPSE), Public key infrastructure (PKI). Among all these security technologies PKI is the principal tool to establish a trusted path for electronic transactions. PKI protects against assaults like disclosure of sensitive information, data alteration etc. The most protective technique is the use of “public key” and “private key”. With the help of these security on the Net, hoping to generate confidence in customers. So that the internet becomes a secure medium.[17]
The ministry of information and technology has setup a National information technology security centre (NITSC) as a part of a multi-pronged approach to control crime.
Top sources in the IT ministry revealed that the move was initiated following intruder attacks in many high profile organization web sites in India. For instance the web defacement of Bhabha Atomic Research Centre, the theft of telephone numbers related information from the system of the chief manager, department of Telecom in Hyderabad by a hacker of Australian origin and the more recently, the web page defacement of the department of electronics by a Pakistani hacker.
The primary objective of this centre is to create awareness among the Indian IT community for IT security and related threats. It is also providing all relevant information and practical advice to help corporate sector to eliminate or mitigate security threats and make their systems secure.
Functioning under the R&D wing of CMC Ltd, the centre disseminates information software tools and issue virus alerts through a web site. Provides newsletters, advisories and booklets. It also offers consultancy services through security audits and training course. One such training course for managers and technical staff is started recently. As e-commerce takes off and transactions go online all care has to be taken. Slipping of Microsoft’s Bill Gates credit card information into the hands of cyber criminals reveals that cyber security is a greatest challenge before us. Day by day budget of cyber security is going high. As per the recent survey most of the companies dealing with e-commerce are wasting more than 15% of their budget on network security.

The Socio-Legal Dimensions of Live-In Relationships

Abstract:
The article deals with the issue of “Socio-Legal Dimensions of Live-In Relationships in India”. Live-In Relationships has been one of the most controversial legal topics in the instant past. The aspects of Live-in relationships was not very clear in India until The Hon’ble Supreme Court gave its landmark judgments on the topic in the year 2010, thereby making its stand firm on the issue and upholding the sovereignty of law in India. Thus, the issue is steadily creeping up in the Indian Society and requires legislation to negate chances of misuse of the relationship.

Indian Society and Perspectives:

The word Live-in has been particularly alien to the Indian Society which has been lighted up particularly in the recent years with the advent of such relationship practiced in the metropolitan cities. Such practice is still a social taboo in a major part of the country which is constituted by villages and towns. A larger and clear picture of India thus will be substantiated by the rural India and not a handful of metros.

In  India there exists only one kind of relationship between an unrelated couple of a male and female. The said social union is termed as “Marriage” which is more of a sacrament and a divine concept and is practiced as a ritual since ages. Therefore the Indian public is unaware of the concept of Live-in. Furthermore, the concept of maitraya karars  is a known phenomena which has been practiced in traces in some parts of Gujarat and also has been brought to the notice of the courts. But in spirit such concept is radically different from live-in concept.. The lack of commitment, the disrespect of social bonds and the lack of tolerance in relationships has made a transit from the sacrament to arranged marriages to love marriages and ultimately to live-in relationships.

The Hindu Marriage Act  considers the legitimacy of child born through such relationships and establishes their succession and property rights. Furthermore, the Protection of  Women from Domestic Violence Act also provides some condolence to such aggrieved parties from any kind of atrocities faced by the females in a live-in relationships. The Supreme Court of India has taken a step further by giving landmark judgments particularly in the year 2010 which provides some clarity to the stand of such relationships in Indian context.

However in Indian context there is a urgent and dire need to recognize such relationship through legislation which would empower both the parties with rights and create obligations with duties thereby confining the ambit of such relationship. Therefore the law so enacted on live in relationship should  keep in mind the basic structure of tradition that prevails in the Indian society.

Legal Status in other countries:

The Legal status and laws governing the live-in relationships is not the same in all the countries. It varies from country to country. Some countries like USA provide a liberal view to the concept whereas, countries of the middle-east considers it a social taboo. There is difference over the property rights of the spouse and also inheritance and succession rights of the children  born through such relationships.

For instance, in United States of America exists the concept of Cohabitation Agreements containing the explicit mention of rights and liabilities under such agreements but still the social status and sanction as enjoyed by Married Couples is not enjoyed by couples in a live-in relationship. Thereby, discouraging attempts of live-in relationships with legal sanction. While in China couples sign a contract for live-in relationship. The child born through such relationships enjoys the same succession and inheritance rights as are enjoyed by children born through marriages.

The concept is well substantiated and given the most vital force in France wherein two adults of opposite sex or same sex can enter into an agreement to live together and organize their lives and thereby enjoy the rights of a married couple and also work towards social welfare. Such agreement can be revoked by both or either of the parties by giving three months prior notice to the other party. Such agreements or pacts are popularly known as “pacte civil de solidarite”. The legal status of the pact was passed by the French National Assembly in 1999 and allowed couples to enter into agreements for a social union. While in England, such couples do not have the same rights as that of a married couple. The Spouse has no inheritance right over the other’s property unless supported by a will.

The status in Scotland is by and far the most clear and substantive by conferring legal aspect to the live-in relationship in the year 2006 . The Section 25 (2) of the Act says that a court of law can consider a person as a co-habitant of another. The three essentials for declaring somebody cohabitant is the length of the period during which they lived together, the nature of the relationship during that period and the nature and extent of any financial arrangements. Whereas Section 28 of the said Act gives a cohabitant the right to apply in court for financial support. This is in case of separation and not death of either partner. Furthermore if a partner dies intestate, the survivor can move the court for financial support from his estate within 6 months.

The position in various countries is different making France and Scotland the most liberal countries as far as live-in relationship concept is concerned. And while most of the countries are legislating laws to bind this new facet of social union and providing legal sanctity to the union. In India, the judgments given by the Supreme Court are further clearing perceptibility of Live-in’s in India and one would clearly presage that soon there would be legislations governing this specific field of law in India as well.

The Legal aspects of Live-In Relationships

A walk-in and walk-out relationship.

In the words of Dhingra J., “There are no legal strings attached to this relationship nor does this relationship create any legal-bond between the partners. People who choose to have live-in relationship cannot complain of infidelity or immorality as live-in relationships are also known to have been between a married man and unmarried woman or vice-versa”

The position of Live-in Relationships is not very clear in the Indian context but the recent landmark judgments given by the Hon’ble Supreme Court provides some assistance when we skim through the topic of Live-In and analyze the radius of the topic in Indian legal ambit.

The couples tied with the knots of live-in relationships are not governed by specific laws and therefore find traces of assistance in other civil laws. The law is neither clear nor is adamant on a particular stand, the status is dwindling.

The Privy Council in A Dinohamy v. W L Blahamy laid down the principle that “Where a man and a woman are proved to have lived together as a man and wife, the law will presume, unless the contrary be clearly proved, that they were living together in consequence of a valid marriage and not in a state of concubinage”. Furthermore the Supreme Court granted legality and validity to a marriage in which the couple cohabited together for a period of 50 years. The Supreme Court held that in such a case marriage is presumed due to a long cohabitation.

Furthermore the Hon’ble Allahabad High Court stated that a live-in relationship is not illegal. Katju J. and Mishra J. stated that, “In our opinion, a man and a woman, even without getting married, can live together if they wish to. This may be regarded as immoral by society, but is not illegal. There is a difference between law and morality.”

The Hon’ble Supreme Court accepted the principle that a long term of cohabitation in a live-in relationship makes it equivalent to a valid marital relationship.  The Supreme Court also held that live-in relationships cannot be considered as an offence as there is no law stating the same.

In the well talked about case of S. Khushboo v. Kanniammal , the Supreme Court gave its landmark judgment and held that there was no law which prohibits Live-in relationship or pre-marital sex. The Supreme court further stated that Live-in relationship is permissible only in unmarried major persons of heterogeneous sex.

In another case the Supreme Court stated that if man and woman are living under the same roof and cohabiting for a number of years, there will be a presumption under section 114 of the Evidence Act, that they Live as husband and wife and the children born to them will not be illegitimate.

Hence the High Courts and the Hon’ble Supreme Court  in a number of decisions delivered until recently have showed the positive signs of recognizing the legitimacy of the live-in relationships and have also shown the inclination for a legislation to be enacted with the objective of protecting the rights of couples in a live-in relationship.

Rights of Women in a Live-in Relationship in India

The Rights of Women in such relationships do not have much condolence except some traces of assistance offered by the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act which covers in its ambit “relationship similar to marriage” or live-in relationships. The definition of “domestic relationship” means a relationship between two persons who live or have, at any point of time, lived together in a shared household, when they are related by consanguinity, marriage, or through a relationship in the nature of marriage, adoption or are family members living together as a joint family . Hence the words in the nature of marriage are self explanatory and buy within its meaning the social concept of live-in.

Furthermore in the recent years the recommendations by various committees and NGO’s have awaken the spirits of justice in the interest of women specially aggrieved by such relationships. Apart from this the Hon’ble Supreme Court has also given landmark judgments make its stand clear on the issue. For instance in the landmark case of D. Veluswami v. D. Patchaimmal  it was held a woman in a live-in relationship is not entitled to maintenance unless she fulfills certain parameters, the Supreme court had observed that merely spending weekends together or a one night would not make it a domestic relationship.

In order to get maintenance, the essential four conditions are:

1.      The couple must hold themselves out to society as being akin to spouses.
2.      They must be of legal age to marry.
3.      They must be otherwise qualified to enter into a legal marriage.
4.      They must be voluntarily cohabited and held themselves out to the world as being akin to spouses for a significant period of time.
The Supreme court observed that not all Live-in relationships will amount to a relationship in the nature of marriage to get the benefit of the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005.If a man has a ‘keep’ whom he maintains financially and uses mainly for sexual purpose and/or as a servant it would not be a relationship in the nature of marriage.
The National Centre for Women made recommendations to the Ministry of Women and Child Development to include female live-in partners within the ambit of section 125 of Cr.PC  in order to establish their rights and make them entitled to right to maintenance. The Hon’ble Court also in the case of Abhijit Auti v. State of Maharashtra and others  supported the above principle and furthermore the Maharashtra Government showed a positive sign by accepting the Malimath Committee  Report and also the Law Commission Report and held that if a live-in relationship continues for a very long time she is entitled to enjoy the rights of a wife but it was recently ruled out that a wife under section 125 of Cr.PC is a divorced wife and the right to maintenance should only be enjoyed by a divorced wife and not by a female partner who merely cohabited with her male partner .Since in case of a live-in relationship there exists no marriage and hence no concept of divorce. Therefore a female partner under live-in relationship should not be construed as a wife under section 125 of the Cr.PC. The decision of the Hon’ble Court is in the righteous spirit as empowering any women who cohabited with a man would result in misuse of the legal provisions under section 125 and would therefore be unfair on the part of the male partner as well. Definition of the word “wife” in section 125 of the Code be amended to include a woman who was living with the man like his wife for a reasonably long period.
The need of the present hour is not to try bringing live-in relationships under the ambit of any existing law but to enact a new different law which would look into the matter of live-in’s separately and would grant rights and obligations on the part of the couples thereby reducing the cases of misuse of existing laws and also to reduce cases of atrocities faced by the female partners under such relationships.
Rights of Child born through a Live-In Relationship  

The Child born through a Live-In Relationships enjoys the same rights of succession and inheritance as are enjoyed by a child through a married couple under the Hindu Marriage Act.  Notwithstanding that marriage is null and void under section 11, any child of such marriage who would have been legitimate if the marriage had been valid, shall be legitimate, whether such child is born before or after the commencement of the Marriage Laws (Amendment) Act, 1976 (68 of 1976)*, and whether or not a decree of nullity is granted in respect of that marriage under this Act and whether or not the marriage is held to be void otherwise than on a petition under this Act.

Thus in order to keep up the spirits of law in the righteous direction and to subside the social evils wherein illegitimate child was denied his rights the Hindu Marriage Act has granted legitimacy to children born through marriages which are not valid. Hence such definition brings within itself the ambit of live-in relationships and children born through such relations.

While still the other laws have not guaranteed such legality to children born through such relationships and therefore the status is dwindling for legal status of children which results in extensive misuse of the provisions and still escape liability. Hence the legality of a child is doubtful in other laws and has to be proved beyond reasonable doubt. Furthermore if the live-in partners decide to separate the question of the future of the child is tossed. Therefore the laws regarding the guardianship should be amended to include within its ambit the guardianship of children born through such relationships.
Conclusion:

The decisions by the Indian Court is discerning as in some cases the Courts have opined that the live-in relationship should have no bondage between the couples because the sole criteria for entering into such agreements is based on the fact that there lies no obligation to be followed by the couples whereas in some instances the Court has shown opposite views holding that if a relationship cum cohabitation continues for a sufficiently and reasonably long time, the couple should be construed as a married couple infusing all the rights and liabilities as guaranteed under a marital relationship.

It also appears strange if the concept of live-in is brought within the ambit of section 125 of the Cr.PC where the husband is bound to pay maintenance and succession as the ground of getting into live-in relationship is to escape all liabilities arising out of marital relations. If the rights of a wife and a live-in partner become equivalent it would promote bigamy and there would arise a conflict between the interests of the wife and the live-in partner. Apart from lacking legal sanction the social existence of such relationships is only confined to the metros, however, when we look at the masses that define India, there exists no co-relation between live-in relationships and its acceptance by the Indian society. It receives no legal assistance and at the same time the society also evicts such relationships. The Parliament should try and enact a separate branch rather than trying to bring live-in within the ambit of the existing laws as such futile approach would further adversely complicate the judicial mechanism.

The Indian Legal system should devise new strategies in order to counter the present existing problems of live-in. The live-in relationships should be presumed as permanent after a specific period of time. Furthermore, the children born through such relationships irrespective of the parents religion should be guaranteed the rights of inheritance, succession etc. The female partner’s role to prove the burden of such relationship should be relaxed. Persons who enter into a live-in relationship with a living spouse should be convicted for bigamy. A separate legislation should only be competent enough to grant assistance to the female partners aggrieved by such relationships. At last, the sooner our society accepts live-in relationships, the better chances the Indian Judiciary has for passing judgments which are in the righteous spirit of law and in the interest of justice, equity and good conscience